When reading through chapter 8 of ” Learning to be old and chapter 8 of Elderhood, there were many things that caught my eye. Ageism is a very prevalent form of discrimination, and it is interwoven into many systems and the daily lives of society. When reading through this topic by both authors, they take a similar understanding through different approaches and wording. But when reading both chapters, they had the same understanding that ageism is harmful and deeply rooted in its effects on older adults and skews their view of themselves. When Aronson does the comparison between geriatrics and old age, I found that to be a very layered statement. It made me think more about how society treats old age, and when old age is deemed an inconvenience, they are cast aside without a second thought. It also reminds me that there is a large lack of resources to help provide for elders, and often leaves them to fend for themselves.
Another thing that is mentioned within chapter 8 of learning to Be Old is how ageism can stem from stereotypes, personal beliefs, and appearances. With the cultural shifts that are currently happening, there has been a rise and especially in women, of the fear of growing and looking older. Miss Dovey’s (2015) article touches on this through literature. While within chapter 8 of Learning to Be Old, Cruishank views it as a decline. Dovey mentions in her article how age is tied to reflection. I can relate to that on a personal level, as I have not only dealt with my age being assumed wrong based on my appearance, but I have also witnessed my mother deal with the same thing. I have also been told by older people that I should be happy that I appear younger than I am, which I find to connect to the appearance statements made by all authors and how appearance is a root cause of ageism.
Overall, other factors that stood out to me included internalized ageism and how language also plays a part in ageism. The authors mention that older adults might often deal with and view their growth and age as inherently negative, and often do not try and advocate for themselves. Another mention was how language can play into ageism, especially with the mention of “Elderspeak”. I found that so interesting because the usage of slow talking and being too sweet is also considered to be harmful to children in development and often seen as dehumanizing, so to see that people will start doing that same thing to elders makes me think of the connection that infantilization and ageism have in this regard.
As for why I personally took this class, it is because I wanted to learn more. I understand that my clientele can be picked and or I can have a specialty, but I believe that learning more about all groups within society is truly beneficial in the long run and important information to have stored. What I have learned has helped shape my already existing opinions and expand my understanding of aging as a whole. As for struggles, I think my biggest struggle was understanding why there is so much resistance to change, but throughout these readings, I have come to the conclusion and learned that where there is resistance, there is often a steady buildup of a lack of understanding and support. As I continue my career and personal life, I will continue to work on my understanding and empathy, and hope that age provides me with the experiences to understand its complex beauty.
Aronson, L. (2019). Elderhood: Redefining aging, transforming medicine, reimagining life. Bloomsbury.
Cruikshank, M. (2013). Learning to be old: Gender, culture, and aging (3rd ed.). Rowman & Littlefield.
Dovey, C. (2015, October 1). What old age is really like. The New Yorker. https://www.newyorker.com/culture/cultural-comment/what-old-age-is-really-like
Hi Allison, I enjoyed reading your post and resonated with some of your points. I never considered “elderspeak” or knew that term existed until taking this course but I am guilty of the “baby talk” with my older clients at work. Also, being told that I look young for my age was always taken as a complement not realizing the negative connotation it has on aging. Taking this course has opened my eyes on things often ignored and I will be more mindful of certain things such as language when working with the older population.
Allison,
I was interested in your discussion of Aronson’s quote about geriatrics is to medicine as aging is to society. I am assuming that is the quote you are discussing? I agree that Aronson was talking about how society treats older adults, but perhaps more importantly she was talking about how the medical profession treats them. The idea that there is a body of medical knowledge related to older adults is a foreign concept, so geriatrics seems irrelevant.
In your discussion of Dovey and Cruikshank, I would suggest that Cruikshank doesn’t view it as delineated, but rather she is challenging the view of aging as decline. I don’t remember Dovey’s discussion about reflection (which doesn’t mean anything), but the issue of “looking your age” certainly came up in the readings she discussed. that is such a complex and loaded phrase and reaction, isn’t it?
In terms of internalized ageism, language is only one way that is perpetuated. And ageist language does so much more damage than just internalized ageism. When we internalize ageism, and I have worked with many older adults who see themselves as “old,” we begin to see ourselves as the oppressor sees us. And ageism itself means that we are confronted with that image through language, movies, literature and society in general.
And finally, I’m not sure that the struggle with aging is a resistance to change. A lot of older adults a quite resilient to change and respond positively to things being different. It’s when we see aging itself as the problem, that’s when ageism takes over. I agree it is partly about change as we age – but it wouldn’t bother us nearly so much if we didn’t live in a society that is constantly telling us to do all we can to avoid it.
Dr P